Enhancing the Promise of Online Education in Kentucky

Technical Details


You can read the entire text in HTML format below or read it in Adobe Acrobat.


CONTACTMark Schirmer (502-564-2851)

Sample details

The data for this analysis come from the Current Population Survey (CPS). The CPS is a monthly survey of about 50,000 households conducted by the Bureau of the Census.(1) The results reported in Policy Note no. 10 are based on an analysis of 2001 CPS data. Our sample is comprised of individuals from across the United States, not just Kentucky. Also, the analysis was limited to individuals 25 years old and older. The question posed in the CPS survey is: This year, have you used the Internet to take a course on-line? Approximately 2.2 percent of those in the sample answered “yes.”

Model details

The dependent variable, whether one has taken a course online, is dichotomous (yes or no). Consequently, we use a multivariate probit model to estimate the effect of the predictor variables (e.g., income, education, race, gender, location, age, and having a computer in the home with Internet access). Based on the model results, we estimate the probability of “the average person” taking a course online at about 0.5 percent if there is not a computer with Internet access in the home. On the other hand, if there is a computer with Internet access in the home, then the probability of taking a course online is 4.3 times higher at 2.3 percent. The model variables are listed below:

  • Income. The CPS does not report the precise household family income. Rather, it is reported in 14 broad categories. We divided these 14 categories into four groups for the analysis: group one ($0-$19,999), group two ($20,000-$34,999), group three ($35,000-$59,999), and group four ($60,000 and over). In our analysis the first quartile is omitted from the model and is the reference group. We also included a variable in the model, MISINC, if the income data are missing for a household.

  • Education. Educational attainment is collected for individuals 15 years and older. There are 16 education categories in the CPS, which range from “less than 1st grade” to doctorate. However, we collapsed these 16 categories into five groups: less than high school, high school, some college, bachelors, and graduate or professional degree. Each is modeled as a “dummy” variable, and the high school variable is omitted from the model as the reference group.

  • Race and Ethnicity. We use five variables to test the effect of race and ethnicity. They are a series of dichotomous variables: non-Hispanic Whites, non-Hispanic Blacks, Hispanics, Asians, and Native Americans. The variable “white” is left out of the model and is therefore the reference group.

  • Age. This variable is also modeled as dichotomous variables: “25 to 49” and “Over 49.” The reference group in the model is “Over 49.”

  • Gender. This variable is equal to 1 for males and 0 for females.

  • Location of Residence. This is a dichotomous variable indicating whether the residence is in a metropolitan area. The variable (URBAN) is set to 1 if metropolitan and 0 if nonmetropolitan.

  • Computer with Internet in the Home. This is a dichotomous variable indicating whether there is a computer with Internet access in the home. The variable (HCI) is set to 1 if “yes” and 0 if “no.”

The probit coefficients and standard errors for the model are presented in Table 1. If we hold all variables at their mean and calculate a predicted probability of taking a course online for the “average” Kentuckian, the model predicts a probability of .121, which is much lower than the sample mean of .022.

Table 1:  Parameter Estimates

Footnotes

1. Refer to http://www.bls.census.gov/cps/cpsmain.htm for detailed information. Return to text.

2. The analyses were done using individual weights that approximately equal the inverse of the probability of being in the sample and normalized to add up to the sample size. This produces the correct standard errors. Return to text.